Your Possible Pasts

Nov 18, 2026 | Note

This post was originally shared with subscribers as a “A Quick Note from JW.” If you enjoy these entries, I’d love to have you join the mailing list (below) and receive future notes before they’re published here.

Well, after 50 days in California, we finally have a date for my jaw surgery: December 29! When I left Maui, we were targeting the third week of October. A few weeks ago, it was sometime in November, hopefully before Thanksgiving. So much for that.

I’ve said before that adaptability is not a substitute for preparation, and I still believe that. But this week, I’ve been thinking about something else: your possible pasts. Pink Floyd is one of my all-time favorite bands, and Roger Waters is one of my favorite lyricists. On The Final Cut, he wrote a song called “Your Possible Pasts,” exploring the lives that might have unfolded differently.

What if I’d known in August that my surgery wouldn’t happen until December 29? I’d probably still be in Maui. Mom’s condo might have a new front door, a laundry-room sink, and a few other improvements. But I would have missed a beautiful family wedding on Oahu, an early Thanksgiving gathering in California, Dad’s birthday dinner, and countless wonderful moments with him. Even these weekly notes would be different.

Leaders routinely revisit the past to learn from experience. But what about revisiting a past that never happened? I think there’s real value in that exercise. Imagining a plausible alternative past forces us to reconsider the assumptions we make about the present. It can reveal consequences we hadn’t anticipated, opportunities we might have overlooked, and experiences whose value only becomes apparent in hindsight. The imagined past isn’t reality, but examining it can bring our understanding of reality into sharper focus.

And the more accurately we understand reality, the better equipped we are to make decisions that produce the outcomes we expect. So perhaps Roger was onto something. Our possible pasts deserve consideration—not because we can change them, but because they may help us take better care of our possible futures. Bravo, Roger. And terrific music, too!